Not All Resistance Is Created Equal

Why how resistance is generated matters as much as how much resistance you experience.

Resistance training is often discussed in terms of weight, repetitions, and intensity.

How much can you lift? How many repetitions can you complete? How difficult does the exercise feel?

These are useful questions.

But they don't tell the whole story.

Two exercises can require substantial muscular effort while challenging the body in very different ways.

Understanding those differences helps coaches, clinicians, and athletes choose exercises that develop the qualities they're actually trying to improve.

Resistance Is More Than a Load

Consider a dumbbell, a resistance band, and a cable machine.

Each can challenge the same muscle groups, but the resistance behaves differently.

A dumbbell is subject to gravity, so the torque it creates around a joint changes with the position of the weight relative to that joint.

A resistance band generally increases its tension as it stretches.

A cable machine applies resistance along the direction of the cable, with the resulting joint demands depending on the exercise and equipment configuration.

None of these tools is automatically better than the others.

They simply provide different mechanical demands.

The important question is how those demands align with the training objective.

Three Exercises. Three Different Resistance Demands.

Consider three variations of a shoulder lateral raise: one using a dumbbell, one using a cable machine, and one using AXIO.

All three can challenge shoulder strength.

But the athlete experiences and manages resistance differently in each exercise.

Dumbbell Lateral Raise

A dumbbell provides gravitational resistance.

As the athlete raises the arm, the distance between the weight's line of gravity and the shoulder changes, altering the torque the shoulder muscles must produce.

At a stationary position, the gravitational resistance remains relatively constant. During movement, acceleration and deceleration introduce additional demands.

The athlete must generate and control muscular force to move and stabilize the weight.

Cable Lateral Raise

A cable machine applies resistance along the direction of the cable.

Changing pulley height, body position, or the angle of movement can alter the direction of resistance and the torque experienced at the shoulder.

This allows coaches to manipulate the loading profile of the exercise without necessarily changing the amount of weight on the machine.

Like dumbbells, cables can challenge muscular strength and coordination, but the direction and distribution of resistance may differ.

AXIO Lateral Raise

With AXIO, the athlete raises and controls the weight of the device against gravity while simultaneously sustaining rotation of its internal mass through a resisted circular channel.

As the mass rotates, the direction of the forces associated with its circular motion continually changes.

The athlete must generate and coordinate muscular force to sustain rotation while also controlling the position and movement of the arm.

These changing force demands remain present even when the arm is held relatively still.

AXIO therefore combines gravitational loading with resisted circular motion, requiring the athlete to manage both simultaneously.

Three exercises can challenge the same muscle groups without creating identical training demands.

The dumbbell emphasizes managing gravitational resistance through movement. The cable allows the direction and leverage of resistance to be manipulated. AXIO combines gravitational loading with resisted circular motion, requiring the athlete to continually generate and coordinate force to sustain rotation.

The question isn't which exercise is harder. It's what each exercise challenges—and whether that challenge matches the training objective.

Similar Effort Doesn't Mean the Same Training Stimulus

Imagine performing a dumbbell exercise and an AXIO exercise that feel equally demanding.

Both may require substantial muscular effort.

Both may contribute to strength development.

But the forces involved, their directions, and the coordination required to manage them differ.

Perceived effort can help describe how challenging an exercise feels, but it doesn't fully explain the mechanical demands or the adaptations that exercise may produce.

An exercise that feels difficult isn't necessarily producing the same stimulus as another exercise that feels equally difficult.

How resistance is generated and managed matters—not just how hard someone is working.

The Direction of Force Matters

Athletic movement requires the body to generate, absorb, and redirect forces in different directions.

Running, throwing, jumping, changing direction, and maintaining balance all involve coordinated muscular responses to changing mechanical demands.

The direction and timing of those forces influence how muscles must respond.

AXIO's circular motion introduces continuously changing directional force demands that the user must manage through coordinated muscular activity.

Changing AXIO's orientation, grip, or direction of rotation can alter those demands.

An athlete may find one rotational direction easier to initiate and sustain than another, even with the same device.

These differences can reflect variations in coordination and force application, providing opportunities to challenge less-developed control strategies.

The objective isn't simply to make an exercise harder.

It's to expose the athlete to different force demands and improve the ability to manage them.

Resistance and Control Work Together

Producing force and controlling force are closely related, but they're not identical.

An athlete may possess substantial muscular strength yet struggle with the timing or coordination required for a particular movement.

Another athlete may demonstrate excellent control at lower resistance levels but lack the strength needed to manage greater loads.

Both capabilities matter.

AXIO brings them together by requiring sufficient force to sustain rotation and sufficient coordination to keep that force appropriately directed.

If force is insufficient or poorly timed, rotation may slow or stop.

Successful performance depends on both the capacity to produce force and the ability to apply it effectively.

Choose Resistance for the Outcome You Want

Traditional resistance training remains essential for developing muscular strength and other physical qualities.

AXIO doesn't replace dumbbells, barbells, bands, or cables.

It provides a different resistance environment that can complement those tools.

For coaches and clinicians, the question shouldn't be which form of resistance is universally best.

It should be which form of resistance provides the most appropriate challenge for the intended adaptation.

A heavier load may be the right choice when the goal is increasing maximal force-producing capacity.

A resisted rotational task may be useful when the goal includes coordinating and regulating force under changing directional demands.

Both approaches can belong in a well-designed training program.

Resistance isn't defined only by how much force is required. How that force is generated, directed, and controlled helps determine what the exercise trains.

Train Force. Master Control.


ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Ted Bezemer, PT, MS, OCS, SCS

Physical Therapist • Orthopedic & Sports Clinical Specialist • Strength Coach
Founder & Inventor of AXIO Centripetal Trainers

PUT THESE PRINCIPLES INTO PRACTICE

AXIO Centripetal Trainers combine strength, dynamic stability, and neuromuscular control through continuous, coordinated force production. Discover how AXIO brings these training principles into practice.